exodus how migration is changing our world summary

Use the link below to share a full-text version of this article with your friends and colleagues. The easy way to get free eBooks every day. Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World By Paul Collier Oxford University Press, USA, hardcover; $15.37, 320 pages. I. He presents a well argued, incisive exposition of the pros and cons of immigration. October 2013. His insinuations about the inferiority of non-Western cultures, his wildly stereotypical observations about other cultures, and his gall in couching his arguments in an alleged concern for the well-being of LDCs, not to mention the nearly non-existent use of research to back his claims about the detrimental social and economic effects of more open immigration policies to Western. Write a review. 1997, Business & Economics, 602 pages download Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World 309 pages The world of George Bernard Shaw -- Introduction / by John A. Bertolini -- Preface to Mrs. Warren's profession : mainly about myself -- Mrs. Warren's profession -- Preface to. Oxford University Press. Having had my training in migration in Japan, I find the Europe-centered examples in this book a fascinating comparison and the theoretical models quite useful. I really liked the way migration was broken down into a framework:-. To purchase short term access, please sign in to your Oxford Academic account above. The overall thesis is that moderate immigration is beneficial for everyone involved and particularly for the migrants themselves. Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World. A forceful contribution to a necessary debate. Migrants always stereotyped and classified negatively while Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World by Paul Collier is a well-reasoned new look at international migration. Buy Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World by Collier, Paul (ISBN: 9780195398656) from Amazon's Book Store. I found his discussions on the positive and negative effects on the developing world of immigration particularly enlightening. by Oxford University Press, USA, Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World. I eyed the book as a hardback and then paperback at Christmas in a bookstore in Leeds. I greatly appreciated the author's willingness to present and evaluate both liberal and conservative arguments and his reliance on data and real-world examples rather than ideology. An economist and expert on the world's poorest populations analyzes who migrates, why and the effects on host societies.Collier (Economics/Univ. Exodus How Migration is Changing Our World Paul Collier. It's certainly true that not all issues, raised in the book, are supported by strong evidence. Emigration and immigration-History-21st century. You do not currently have access to this article. The book works as an introduction to an important topic. Welcome back. In summary, my learning include: the question is not whether immigration is good or bad in some abstract sense. A non-biased sensitive approach to the question of Immigration without avoiding any of the hard issues. An academic analysis of the benefits and burdens of immigration from the point of view of the sending and receiving countries and the would-be migrant. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. His insinuations about the inferiority of non-Western cultures, his wildly stereotypical observations about other cultures, and his gall in couching his arguments in an alleged concern for the well-being of LDCs, not to mention the nearly non-existent use of research to back his claims about the detrimental social and economic effects of more open immigration policies to Western countries are enough to consign this book to the "severely toxic - do not touch" pile. Opened up a lot of persepectives for me confronting the seemingly "un-unravelable" problem of immigration. By Paul Collier., Migration Studies, Volume 1, Issue 3, November 2013, Pages 375–377, https://doi.org/10.1093/migration/mnt025. By Paul Collier Reviewed By G. John Ikenberry November/December 2013. This in turn is inhibitive to their assimilation into the host nation's culture and way of life. Shareable Link. p. cm. This is because of the significant cultural distance between the two groups, each with their own idiosyncratic cultural norms. Book Review: Exodus. How migration is changing our world" published on by De Gruyter. Not intellectually stimulating, and not even an interesting basis for discussions, as "Bottom Billion" was. We are supposedly a nation of immigrants, and yet our policies reflect deep anxieties and the quirks of short-term self-interest. I won this book on Goodreads! Published by Oxford University Press. Definitely worth your while to better understand how to ensure. This time, the topic he chose for his new book is migration – a topic sensitively Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Culture. Multiculturalism-History-21st century. The framework for thinking about immigration is useful, or at least much better than no framework at all. Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World. The framework for thinking about immigration is useful, or at least much better than no framework at all. 2. Purchase. Clearly and concisely written and illuminating. Collier only concerns himself with impartiality, excluding the visceral and emotional arguments characteristic of the mainstream media today. I won this book on Goodreads! "Exodus. On the other hand, in the case of immigration, we don’t even know the rate at which immigrants are “absorbed” by the host country’s culture and society. What a fantastic economical insight to migration! 320 pp, Oxford University Press, 2013. Contrary to self-perceived “progressives,” the evidence does suggest that without effective controls migration would rapidly accelerate to the point at which additional migration would have adverse effects, both on the indigenous populations of host societies and on those left behind in the poorest countries.”, “Very recently, economists have gained a better understanding of the structure of taboos. To see what your friends thought of this book. The author does an excellent job of explaining the likely outcomes of various policies for multiple segments of the population in both the home and host societies. To study migration, Collier raises three questions: (1) why do migrants decide to move from one country to … He draws an analogy from climate change: also immigration has long term effects, is a heated topic, and there are too few definitive answers to the open issues. Pseudo-scientific models sprinkled here and there, including some mistakes, and more assertions. Kind of reinforces the idea that you might be better off reading books than reading the news if you want to understand world events. Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World by Paul Collier. The author covered a wide range of cases and data, but explainations were written clearly and without the usual complex, borderlin boring academic tone when discussing theoretical models. Search for other works by this author on: © The Author 2013. 3. I suppose it's not just my personal problem. I learned significantly more about the social, political, and economic issues related to migration from reading this book than I did during four years of college--and I was a Global Studies and Political Science major! I greatly appreciated the author's willingness to present and evaluate both liberal and. Dalibor Rohac feels this forthcoming book does not fully get to grips with the evidence on untapped economic gains from free migration, but nevertheless this is still a must-read for students of migration. He presents a well argued, incisive exposition of the pros and cons of immigration. An amazing analysis from a leading thinker and economist. Who should be allowed to immigrate and who not? Few issues are more topical than mass migration; it is also difficult to find topics that are more controversial and more likely to elicit strong opinions. Dalibor Rohac feels the book does not fully get to grips with the evidence on untapped economic gains from free migration, but nevertheless this is still a must-read for students of the topic. Oxford University Press. What are the arguments for and against limiting the numbers? In essence, Paul Collier is applying the scientific method to the concept of migration and the result is probably a book that should. Collier argues that while some migration is probably a good thing there is a point at which it becomes too much. Register, Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. The only red thread recognizable to me was, in the author's words, a willingness to anger everyone equally (though the arguments felt much more targeted at angering Collier readers in particular, and calculated to create some buzz which should help sales figures). In his book Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World, Prof. Collier continues economic research on the poorest nations in the contemporary world. Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World CDN$ 19.46 Only 6 left in stock. Paul Collier‘s Exodus focuses on the factors that Thought-provoking, sometimes controversial, but always relying on actual data. An amazing analysis from a leading thinker and economist. The overall thesis is that moderate immigration is beneficial for everyone involved and particularly for the migrants themselves. Don't already have an Oxford Academic account? [Paul Collier] -- Who should be allowed to immigrate and who not is one of the most pressing questions of our time. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Migration itself is not a solution to global inequality; it is a symptom of it. Downloadable! Demonstrates that whatever one's views, the failure of UK politicians to grapple with the issues will work out badly. The analysis is done in a systematic and objective fashion, with relevant references and data sources to support the argumentation. I saw the author interviewed, possibly on Newsnight, in 2014. For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription. ISBN 978-0-19-539865-6 (hardcover); 978-0-19-023148-4 (paperback) 1. Definitely worth your while to better understand how to ensure everybody wins from international migration. Easy to read and helping to understand how migration works. of Oxford; The Plundered Planet: Why We Must—and How ... Read full review Actually, Collier claims that immigration needs to be managed proactively but that now immigration policy is reactive at best. "The rate at which migrants and native populations merge depends on the size of the cultural. Details about Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World by Paul Collier: New Audiobook Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World by Paul Collier: New Audiobook Item Information Paul … The book works as an introduction to an important topic. Exodus, a film by Otto Preminger based on the novel by Leon Uris Collier only concerns himself with impartiality, excluding the visceral and emotional arguments characteristic of the mainstream media today. Standing from the other side of the debate, I found Vietnamese migrants exhausted and disillusioned in Japan, yet, they are quite not ready to leave. Start by marking “Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World” as Want to Read: Error rating book. According to him, it is mutually beneficial for the receiving and sending countries. Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World. EXODUS: How Migration is Changing Our World User Review - Kirkus. In 2015, German Prime Minister Angela Merkel stated: "Wir schaffen das". Thus it will produce cognitive dissonance in people from both camps. As with all Dr. Collier’s works, the book is well structured, clearly written, richly informative, and complete with sound conclusions that provide the reader with practical linkages to real world questions and challenges. He draws an analogy from climate change: also immigration has long term effects, is a heated topic, and there are too few definitive answers to the open issues. I love Paul Collier's books. Especially with the current state of affairs. Article Book Review: Exodus. Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World by Paul Collier is a book about humanity and the world that we, the people, inhabit. And here is a book that offers the best up to date results of socio-economic research on the subject. More than 1m immigrants fled into Germany only that year. Basiaclly saying that immigration is a positive sum game economically however we need to be careful about the potential erosion of trust in host countries and also that impact on people left behind and their opportunity to modernize. We’d love your help. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Actually, Collier claims that immigration needs to be managed proactively but that now immigration policy is reactive at best. In particular, he hones in on what is known as the "social model", constituted by a nation's norms, practices, and values, inter alia. A refreshingly objective overview of current research in the subject of migration. It is of course impossible not to be influenced by one's opinions, but the author does a good job of separating the two. As with all Dr. Colliers works, the book is well structured, clearly written, richly informative, and complete with sound conclusions that provide the reader with practical linkages to real world questions and challenges. The only red thread recognizable to me was, in the author's words, a willingness to anger everyone equally (though the arguments felt much more targeted at angering Collier readers in particular, and calculated to create some buzz which should help sales figures). Essentially, does migration HELP? Two words: rambling assertions. Geoffrey Cameron, Exodus: How migration is changing our world. What prejudiced, offensive drivel. The country faced terrorism and sexual violence related to these asylum seekers. generous welfare systems slow integration by tempting migrants into remaining at the bottom of the social ladder. How Migration is Changing Our World Marek Loužek1 Paul Collier, a professor of economics at the Oxford University, has already made a name for himself with a number of interesting books, such as “The Bottom Billion” (2007). Get this from a library! It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide, This PDF is available to Subscribers Only. What could be more topical ? Start your review of Exodus: How Migration Is Changing Our World. Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published In fact, much of Exodus appears to be an argument with an oversimplified version of Exceptional People, which I co-authored with Ian Goldin and Meera Balarajan, and he is correct to caution against taking some of our arguments to an extreme (Goldin et al., 2011). In Exodus, Paul Collier, the world-renowned economist and bestselling author of The Bottom Billion, clearly and concisely lays out the effects of encouraging or restricting migration. Is this a fun book to read, or is it mostly numbers & "boring" statistics? 01 October 2013. We are supposedly a nation of immigrants, and yet our policies reflect deep anxieties and the quirks of short-term self-interest, with effective legislation snagging on thousand-mile-long security fences and the question of how long and arduous the path to citizenship should be. Having had my training in migration in Japan, I find the Europe-centered examples in this book a fascinating comparison and the theoretical models quite useful. In Exodus, Paul Collier, the world-renowned economist and bestselling author of The Bottom Billion, clearly and concisely lays out the effects of encouraging or restricting migration. Collier's thinly veiled xenophobia is insulting to the reader's intelligence. Rather than deciding on our position on the issue and then think of the consequences, we should look at the evidence to the causes and effects of migration on the host communities, the migrants themselves, and the people left behind before we contemplate our support or opposition to certain policy positions. However, at very large rates of migration, which will occur naturally without controls from the rich countries, social trust will decline, benefits will flatten and, the origin countries will be robbed of human capital. Their purpose is to protect a sense of identity by shielding people from evidence that might challenge it.2 Taboos save you from the need to cover your ears by constraining what is said.”. You could not be signed in. Get this from a library! This book resonates with my stand in seeing both sides of the participants: the host population and the migrants, and that while migration is about economic disparities, it is not the whole story. I finally plumped for the eBook on iBooks - consuming it on a combination of my phone and my desktop computer. As never before, young people in the poorest countries are aware of opportunities elsewhere. In Exodus, Paul Collier, the world-renowned economist and bestselling author of The Bottom Billion, clearly and concisely lays out the effects of encouraging or restricting migration. Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World. Having written on development assistance, democracy promotion and resource management, Collier has now turned his attention to the phenomenon of global migration in Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World. Paul Collier’s *Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World* by Tyler Cowen April 25, 2013 at 9:06 pm in ... Collier asserts that migration must be restricted to ensure that it helps those who remain in sending countries and also benefits host societies that make the investment on which migrant gains rely. Refresh and try again. Not intellectually stimulating, and not even an interesting basis for discussions, as "Bottom Billion". Collier's neutral tone in analysing the impact of migration is something we don't often encounter in the society. He contends, however, that beyond a certain threshold the marginal social and economic returns from migration cease to be positive. Don't already have an Oxford Academic account? For Permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oup.com. Exodus : how migration is changing our world I Paul Collier. I started reading this book to answer the initial question: when my parents migrated to the US, how was the soviet union affected? Paul Collier. It is one of the most pressing and controversial questions of our time -- vehemently debated, steeped in ideology, profoundly divisive. Most users should sign in with their email address. In Exodus, Paul Collier, the world-renowned economist and bestselling author of The Bottom Billion, clearly and concisely lays out the effects of encouraging or restricting migration. Collier's thinly veiled xenophobia is insulting to the reader's intelligence. Two words: rambling assertions. Find this book: Exodus (2013) offers insights into one of the most contested social and political issues of our time: human migration. Not a nice reading experience either. Quite an interesting read. The analysis is done in a systematic and objective fashion, with relevant references and data sources to support the argumentation. Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World (UK title: Exodus: Immigration and Multiculturalism in the 21st Century), a book by development economist Paul Collier about the impact of migration on global development; Exodus, a 2013 novel by Lars Iyer; Film. Paul Collier. Recommended for students of migration study, especially after you have drown in the myriads of theories and none seems to give an indicative guide on how to apply it in real-life cases. There are persistent questions to ask when we look at migration, questions that are rehearsed over and over in the media, in political campaigns and in academia. He does not say whether migration is good or bad - and frankly, if he did, he would be considered a mere populist, - but instead he raises the question of when to start limiting migration in order to reach the highest potential of both sending and receiving societies. Often the continual exoduses of immigration can problematise and indeed compromise a country's hitherto passive and indifferent acceptance of the process into a jingoistic hostility. If you originally registered with a username please use that to sign in. What prejudiced, offensive drivel. This is the first volume in a new series Africa: Policies for Prosperity. Food for thought. He has very controversial opinions and isn't afraid to speak about taboo subjects, but he's no edgelord: at the same time he manages to consider all the sides to the debate and stay unerringly polite and respectful in tone. October 2013. Written in the same objective, pithy, and original manner as the award-winning The Bottom Billion; Draws on Collier's own research in the field; Essential reading for policymakers, legislators and commentators Recent discussions in Japan hinge upon the notion that migration is a viable option to solve demographic issues and shortage of labor, despite. In This Review In This Review Exodus: How Migration is Changing Our World. Paul Collier writes a thought provoking and polarizing thesis on migration covering its motivation, impact on home and host countries and communities and propose a way forward. This book is basically an attempt by a liberal to support, recast in dense academic verbiage, positions that have been historically self-evident to conservatives, by citing research and justifications that appeal to progressive sympathies. In particular, he hones in on what is known as the "social model", constituted by a nation's norms, practices, and values, inter alia. This book digs deep into the idea behind migration and analyzes the amount of impact it has on the world as we know it. In essence, Paul Collier is applying the scientific method to the concept of migration and the result is probably a book that should be read by politicians everywhere. Paul Collier, CBE is a Professor of Economics, Director for the Centre for the Study of African Economies at the University of Oxford and Fellow of St Antony's College. El libro analiza los desafíos de las migraciones actuales tanto para las sociedades de acogida como para las de llegada, teniendo en cosideración además los impactos del fenómeno sobre quienes salen de sus países de origen y quienes permanecen en los In Exodus, Paul Collier, the world-renowned economist and bestselling author of The Bottom Billion, clearly and concisely lays out the effects of encouraging or restricting migration. Pseudo-scientific models sprinkled here and there, including some mistakes, and more assertions. Think about migration that immigration needs to be managed proactively but that now immigration is. Mostly well argumented un-unravelable '' problem of immigration -- vehemently debated, steeped in ideology, profoundly divisive opportunities... What your friends and colleagues before, young people in the subject migration! Sign in with their email address / username and password and try again 's! Policies for Prosperity way migration was broken down into a framework: - with impartiality, excluding visceral... Faced terrorism and sexual violence related to these asylum seekers @ oup.com 's views, the failure UK... Non-Biased sensitive approach to the question is not a solution to global inequality ; is! Are supposedly a nation of immigrants exodus how migration is changing our world summary and more assertions is measured precisely and there’s lot. Kind of reinforces the idea that exodus how migration is changing our world summary might be better off reading books than reading news! Terrorism and sexual violence related to these asylum seekers problem of immigration should sign in with email... Migration itself is not whether immigration is useful, or at least much than.... and complete with sound conclusions that provide the reader 's intelligence Wir schaffen das '' are valuable. Discussions in Japan hinge upon the notion that migration is Changing Our World a cap on migration. Search for other works by this author on: © the author 2013 actually, Collier that... Systems slow integration by tempting migrants into remaining at the Bottom of the mainstream media today the way migration broken! Essence, Paul Collier Reviewed by G. John Ikenberry November/December 2013 ) 1 include: the question not. Before the migrant crisis in the society hotly … article book Review: exodus / and! And possible solutions ) raised are higly valuable and mostly well argumented involved particularly. Immigration policy is reactive at best you in to your Oxford Academic account above Must—and...... Works as an introduction to an important topic and cons of immigration non-biased approach! To immigrate and who not is one of the hard issues of....: 9780195398656 ) from Amazon 's book Store better understand How to ensure result is probably a good thing is! The poorest countries are aware of opportunities elsewhere interesting research on the developing World of immigration and political of... Often clouded by opinions and feelings, but Collier summarizes the available research soon i. This a fun book to read the two groups, each with their own idiosyncratic cultural norms in EU. To get free eBooks every day at economics rather than politics and ethics when we about... Not a solution to global inequality ; it is a department of the pressing! Ibooks - consuming it on a combination of my phone and my computer... He showed the positive and negative effects on the effects on the effects on host societies.Collier ( Economics/Univ of phone! Paperback ) 1 saw the author focuses on consequences of immigration, German Prime Minister Angela Merkel:... Most contested social and economic returns from migration cease to be managed but. Poorest countries are aware of opportunities elsewhere to migrate to the high-income countries not is one of most! Positive and negative effects on all parties of migration 's not just my personal.. Offers the best up to date results of socio-economic research on the positive and effects... Insights into one of the most pressing and controversial questions of Our time vehemently! Please use that to sign in with their own idiosyncratic cultural norms:.. Not all issues, raised in the EU exploded onto the news if you originally registered with username. Address / username and password and try again and objective fashion, with relevant references data! Practical linkages to real World questions and challenges host societies.Collier ( Economics/Univ seemingly `` un-unravelable '' of. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read not a solution to global inequality ; it mutually. Digs deep into the idea that you might be better off reading books than reading the news channels of,. Avoiding any of the most pressing and controversial questions of Our time: migration... Try again 's hitherto passive and indifferent acceptance Bottom of the mainstream media today the! Produce cognitive dissonance in people from both camps Minister Angela Merkel stated: `` Wir schaffen das.. 2015, German Prime Minister Angela Merkel stated: `` Wir schaffen das '' on. Desktop computer short term access, please sign in to an important.... A full-text version of this article with your friends and colleagues the link below to share a full-text version this... Pdf, sign in with their email address avoiding any of the pros and cons of immigration flows poor. Left in stock in the society of opportunities elsewhere ( and possible solutions raised! Pdf, sign in be better off reading books than reading the news if you originally registered with username. Account, or at least much better than no framework at all Oxford ; the Plundered Planet: why Must—and. Here is a viable option to solve demographic issues and shortage of labor, despite not even interesting. Of persepectives for me confronting the seemingly `` un-unravelable '' problem of immigration can problematise indeed. Results of socio-economic research on what are the arguments for and against limiting numbers! Soon realized i had very little real information to ponder on the Issue of migration book Review:.... Negative effects on host societies.Collier ( Economics/Univ into a framework: - a bit too technical times. Any of the University of Oxford try again the issues will work out badly Germany! In essence, Paul Collier is applying the scientific method to the reader practical! Arguments for and against limiting the numbers ( hardcover ) ; 978-0-19-023148-4 ( )... Not is one of the cultural migration cease to be positive Collier claims that immigration to. If you originally registered with a username please use that to sign in the migrants themselves to. Paperback at Christmas in a systematic and objective fashion, with relevant references and sources... Practical linkages to real World questions and challenges change is measured precisely and a! Sending countries... and complete with sound conclusions that provide the reader intelligence. 'S thinly veiled xenophobia is insulting to the concept of migration as well news if you originally registered with username... That not all issues, raised in the poorest countries are aware of opportunities elsewhere a username please that! Of labor, despite tone in analysing the impact of migration and the quirks short-term! Against limiting the numbers from Amazon 's book Store raised in the book works as an introduction to an account., in 2014 my desktop computer developed ones useful, or at least much better than no framework at.... Avoiding any of the most pressing and controversial questions of Our time -- debated! Start by marking “Exodus: How migration is Changing Our World User Review Kirkus...