You can use the same amount of margarine as you would use of butter when making your substitution. The small lumps of fat are then compressed together to form the familiar yellow block. Copyright text © 2017 - 2020 by Do You Cook With Me. There is no 100% healthful option when it comes to these two spreads. But it’s not just about how it looks on the outside it’s also the inside texture. By the way “butter” here is butter. Here is a quick video to get you started on the differences: Margarine is created through a chemical process. Margarine products made with 80 percent fat behave most like stick butter, which by definition contains at least 80 … Although good substitutes when cooking or coating toast, tub butters won't give the desired results in crumbly baked concoctions such as cookies. Darned milk allergy. Margarine, which can contain more water and less fat, may make thin cookies that spread out while baking (and may … I have used both in cookies and so I would just go with what the recipe suggests. Shortening, which is also made from vegetable oil, is another cholesterol-free option. It can generally be used in place of butter unless the distinct flavor of butter is key to the recipe, as with butter cookies. My theory: The shortbread cookies made with butter will still be the most tender overall. If it is not refrigerated at a cool temperature, the frosting will stay soft. When substituting margarine for butter, make sure you choose margarine that: By following these rules, you’ll be making a more accurate substitution in your recipe. Whether cooking or baking, butter and margarine can be swapped one for another at a 1:1 ratio—but you will often notice both textural and flavor differences. We are becoming increasingly aware of the effect our diet has on our health, and this extends to using products like butter. Yes. It adds a nice flavor and texture for cookies and pastries, because of the fat it contains. They are both acceptable. Frosting made with margarine is much softer than frosting made with butter. Especially with cookies.....there may be more or less spread, depending on how much you cream the butter and sugars. You don't have to run to your nearest grocery store for margarine. FoodHow.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Either way, there's the all-important question: Can you substitute margarine for butter in baking recipes? Most margarine uses vegetable oils made from soybeans, cottonseed and corn. Nutritionist, researcher, and writer, interested in everything nutrition and food-related. If you find yourself in the middle of baking but don't have butter, don't panic. Bottom line: You can use either butter or margarine when making these types of cookies. They can substitute each other in most recipes, but different factors will help you decide if you should use one or the other when baking. Margarine can also be used for baking, but it doesn’t have as nice of a flavor as butter. Butter is well-known and appreciated, even from ancient times, as a versatile product from churning milk. Please. The Best Margarine Cookies Recipes on Yummly | Citrus Cookies, Almond Cookies, Welsh Cookies. The most notable difference between margarine and butter is that the former is made from plant oils and is heavily processed. Is it okay if I substitute?? In contrast, butter is derived from dairy and is rich in cholesterol and saturated fats. There are several things you can use as a butter substitute for cookies. (It begins as cream, after all, and margarine is made from vegetable oil.) Some people confuse margarine and shortening with each other because they are both similar, non-butter products. Margarine, on the other hand, is ready to spread as soon as you take it out of the refrigerator. I want a small one. 1 cup unsalted butter (or margarine), softened 1/2 cup icing sugar 2 tbsp granulated sugar. Generally speaking, however, shortening is a better substitute for butter than margarine. 3 Easy Ways on How to Make Store Bought Frosting Better, https://www.pinterest.com/cookwithsophia/. Just be smart about when you make a substitution, and you’ll still end up with a great final product. What is lard? It’s your best tool for imparting richness, flavor and helping you achieve everything from perfectly roasted veggies to cakes (like this chocolate beauty) … Here is what to expect when doing the swap: Read Also: Here Is A Super Simple Way to Make Clarified Butter. For example, in recipes that require shortening, it makes a better substitute than butter because of its consistency, mild flavor, and better heat resistance. I didn’t like the Toll House cookies when they switched the recipe from using shortening to using butter, so I went back to the original recipe with shortening and have used it ever since. Butter is a bit different, it spreads a bit more, not much, but a little. Besides pasteurized cream, the only other ingredient that is added to butter is salt, and it is option. I found this awesome recipe in a book which needs: 1/4 Pound plus 4 tablespoons butter or margarine 7 Tablespoons soft light brown sugar 1 3/4 Cups flour And I'm a) allergic to soy and lactose b) not able to get any more ingredients. It shouldn’t be a scary word, especially in the kitchen. Margarine is a very common spreadable nowadays; there are even many recipes that suggest using it over butter. Lard and beef fat are too heavy for most cookies, and bacon fat too strongly flavored. If you need to make a large batch of cookies right away for people who aren’t cookie connaisseurs or need to watch their cholesterol and saturated fat intake, go for margarine. Both contain saturated fats that raise LDL cholesterol, which is bad for your arteries. For the love of cookies do not substitute margarine (or light butter or a butter substitute) when the recipe calls for butter. In fact, if you want a baking recipe to turn out you can almost never substitute anything for the specific butter called for. Please take my advise however. Since they weigh practically the same, you can exchange. Share with me in the comments, and then share this article with any friends who might appreciate the advice. That will … See the very first photo to see why we love the butter cookie the most for flavor and texture. And how much would I need to use? Mix fifty percent butter/margarine to fifty percent flaxseed powder and add to the baking batter. When you are making cookies, chill the dough before putting it in the oven. Keep in mind that you cannot simply substitute butter for shortening in equal portions. Meanwhile, margarine is a good source of sodium and vitamin E and is usually a good choice for vegans. Read Also: Margarine and shortening have the same properties in cookies. If you cool the dough, you will lessen the risk of this. Should you choose to use soy butter for baking cookies, you can make super healthful cookies in a recipe that contains soy nut butter, margarine, soy milk and vanilla. You can use margarine but, there will be a difference in taste. I use peanut butter instead of margarine, butter or shortening in Oatmeal Cookies. For some, they’re minor enough not to matter, and others actually prefer the effect margarine has on a cake or cookie recipe. See recipes for Pretzel no bake cookie, Sugar•Cookies too. And don't substitute the same amount: try two thirds to three fourths as much oil. Cookies made with coconut oil instead of butter will generally turn out OK, although they'll be a bit more crunchy. I’ve made reasonably good chocolate chip cookies using margarine. Butter is the star of recipes like butter-cookies and butter-cake. Soo good! Striving to inform, encourage, and inspire all the readers to make healthy and informed choices when it comes to cooking, food, diet, and nutrition. Which texture you prefer will come down to personal taste. It is more stable at room temperature, and it resists heat better, which could make it a better option for heat-resistant creams and fluffier cakes.Still, doing the swap is easy, and it could become your special touch in the kitchen! 1 cup unsalted butter (or margarine), softened 1/2 cup icing sugar 2 tbsp granulated sugar. Can you safely substitute butter? Can I use margarine instead of butter? Butter was an expensive and non practical alternative, but the bakery would always make the best buttery baguette toasts. Why should you use a Flora? But before you make that substitution, you will want to understand why the recipe calls for butter and what it does for the recipe. The simple answer is that yes, you can use margarine instead of butter. In fact, if you want a baking recipe to turn out you can almost never substitute anything for the specific butter called for. Join the discussion today. Margarine is not quite there yet when it comes to the buttery taste of its dairy counterpart, but it is getting closer. Margarine, of course, has its perks as well. As a cook, you should know and love fat. Fabulous! However, I have a feeling that the batch made with I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter will … When a recipe calls for butter I use margarine. Margarine will start to melt during this process and can make the entire cake denser if this happens. Yes, you can, but you have to be prepared for how it will turn out. Margarine is an unsaturated butter substitute made with at least 80 percent fat by weight and flavoring from dairy products. It is more suitable for cookies, which will become denser and sweet. You can also substitute shortening for butter in equal amounts. The higher fat content of butter keeps the sponge tender and moist while also giving it a delicious buttery flavor that you won't get when using margarine. In cakes and breads, the substitution is rarely noticeable when using shortening vs. butter. Choose margarine that is at least 80 percent vegetable oil to get as close to the traditional cookie texture as possible. 7 Amazing Substitutes For Tarragon, How To Substitute Margarine For Butter: The Easy Solution (2019 Edition), What Is The Best Goat Cheese Substitute? If you don’t have butter, you don’t have to give up on your recipe. Can I Substitute Margarine For Butter While Baking? As an Amazon Associate We earn from qualifying purchases. Rather than run to the store, I decided to use margarine instead! Those made with cream cheese were unappealingly hard; which makes sense, given the fact that cream cheese is lower fat than any of the other choices to begin with, and I used a lower-fat cream cheese to boot. I never had cc cookies elsewhere that were as good as mine, an opinion shared by my now-grown kids. These cookies were all the exact same recipe, but the first used softened butter, then margarine, shortening and good quality coconut oil and clearly they all turned out different. Can I use margarine instead of butter? They are both acceptable. This is the most popular one. But it’s not just about how it looks on the outside it’s also the inside texture. The answer to these two questions is yes, and yes. Yes you can. Butter is great for baking. Here are some recipes that call for butter and should never be made with margarine: It is because these recipes need a perfect balance of both moisture and fat to succeed. Most margarine is vegan and lactose-free, whereas butter is not. Practical Tips For Swapping These Ingredients, Here Is A Super Simple Way to Make Clarified Butter. Margarine. Here's how to use each fat the right way. Butter is, of course, made from animal milk, whereas margarine is composed mainly of refined vegetable oil and water. Most margarine is packed with trans fats, which are best avoided; if you do choose to use margarine, look for one that is completely free of trans fats and go to town on delicious recipes like these creamy caramels. When it comes to cookies, using butter or margarine is about personal preference. These cookies were all the exact same recipe, but the first used softened butter, then margarine, shortening and good quality coconut oil and clearly they all turned out different. TL; DR: Can You Use Butter in Place of Margarine and Vice Versa? When it comes to texture, recipes with butter will be moister and more compact, while margarine will give a drier result with more air pockets, which is common to see in bread and cakes. So what do you do? The main difference in taste comes down to fat content. Margarine was invented in 1869, when H. Mege Mouries patented a process to obtain a spreadable from beef fat as a cheap substitute for butter. I'm Sophia, food blogger, dog lover, homemade cooking and travel passion. While some people prefer cookies that are thin and crispy, others like them soft and chewy, while still others prefer a combination of the two. And “shortening” here is Crisco baking sticks. A blend of oils and fats is emulsified to create a spread. I use marg. Can You Use Butter Instead of Margarine in Baking? Can I use butter in a molasses cookie recipe instead of margarine I Stack Exchange Network Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow , the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Growing up in Brazil, we always used margarine for everything. Always use the "stick margarine" if you are going to use it at all. Recipes with butter will be moister and more tender. But can you substitute margarine for butter when making frosting? These cookies are wonderful and very tasty. So do you know what I can use instead of butter/margarine? 17 Effective Substitutes for Eggs When Making Pancakes. Join the discussion today. How To Substitute Margarine For Butter: The Easy Solution, It’s possible to buy a both dairy and dairy-free margarine. When Should I Not Use Margarine As A Substitute? Butter, on the other hand, does not need heavy processing and usually has fewer preservatives; therefore, its shelf life (and the shelf life of the goods made with it) is shorter. When it comes to deep-frying, butter or margarine cannot be a substitute. Read more: How To Choose The Best Convection Oven. This happened to me recently. Hi,Today is Saturday,December 1,2018.I knew there was a recipie for chocolate chip cookies using margarine,I googled your website,which I am a proud member of,and came up with this recipie,for chocolate chip cookies using margarine,not many recipes use margarine,I’m so glad,because I’m out of butter.Cookies came out beautiful,the dough in resting in the … Simply put: yes! You can use a 1:1 ratio of oil (or shortening) for the butter. You shouldn't have any issue when substituting butter for shortening here. Using margarine instead of butter can lead to cookies that burn easily, spread out too much, or don’t get the right texture. You should never substitute margarine for butter when the flavor of butter is important to the final product, such as when making butter cookies. Cookies made with butter are usually crisper than chewy cookies made with shortening, but the flavor is richer with butter. Just NO. If you use margarine instead of butter, chances are very low that you will get the right balance. Try replacing just half the butter with oil, which still cuts your saturated fats but retains much of the cookies’ original texture. Hydrogenated margarine contains high levels of trans fats that are bad news for your heart. So if you need a substitute for shortening in cookies, a one-to-one butter swap will work great. Margarine is slightly less calorific, with around 60% fat content. After feeling oh so guilty about letting you all know I use margarine half and half with butter in some cookie recipes because I think it improves the cookie texture, I decided I'd better do a little experiment to see 'for sure' if there was really a different between basic cookies baked with... A. Can I use butter in a molasses cookie recipe instead of margarine I Stack Exchange Network Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow , the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. The low-fat version that has half the fat content of the conventional butter comes from adding gelling agents, aroma, and colorings to make it look like the real thing. This is one of the most commonly asked baking questions, particularly those that don’t want to use a dairy-based product in their baking. Nowadays, its production is quite different. However, I have a feeling that the batch made with I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter will give the original recipe a run for it’s money from a flavour standpoint. Many people don’t remember that they need butter to make frosting until they’ve already run out of butter making their cakes or cupcakes. I grew up with those butter-less cakes. PLEASSSE HELP! B. The top horizontal row were the cookies with all margarine, the middle row were the cookies with half butter and half margarine, and the all butter cookies were on the bottom row. Spreadable tub margarine or liquid ones are made with less hydrogenated, margarine contains high levels of trans fats that are bad news for your heart. Substituting Butter for Margarine The easiest, most fool-proof way to ensure your baked goods will turn out the most similar is using butter. I had run out of shortening and margarine and had to do the cookies for a bake sale. https://www.allrecipes.com/recipe/25052/favorite-peanut-butter-cookies It’s mainly made from vegetable oils that go through industrial processes to obtain solid fat from a liquid (e.g., from seed oil like sunflower, safflower, cottonseed, soybean, rapeseed, or olive oil). (Except the hard stick one). The dough will feel greasy if you use oil, … We also participate in affiliate programs with Clickbank, CJ, and other websites. As long as you are careful! If not can you give me a recipe for chocolate chip cookies that does require margarine?? Margarine that comes in a stick has the most trans fat, while margarine bought in a tub has nearly no trans fat. In many things you can use margarine, lard, or shortening instead of butter, or a combination of any of them. These are still doable with margarine, but the final result will be different: They will lose their aroma and that "homemade" taste people know and love. There is no water, no steam, no nothing added during the process. Also, margarines’ fat contents vary, so read the label. First, try to use butter instead of margarine. Make sure that margarine is well chilled before you start creaming the margarine and sugar. I only have margarine and no butter. On most cake recipes back then, it called for margarine or butter, and a lot of recipes used oil instead. No Bake Cookies – In most cases, the butter helps the cookies set up, so you’ll want to use a highly-saturated oil, like coconut oil or palm oil (or shortening). For 1 cup margarine, substitute 1 cup butter or 1 cup shortening plus ¼ teaspoon salt. The fat content of margarine can be anywhere from 30 to 80%, and you usually buy it by the stick. Somehow, I had run out of butter but did not realize this until I was halfway through making a batch of cookies. Fantastic Options For Every Recipe. I never buy butter. The ones with the highest fat contents are best for baking. I am Jewish and according to our dietary laws we are not supposed to use meat and dairy products together, so I know a lot about replacing margarine for butter in recipes. B utter has a high level of fat (80%) while some margarine only have 30%. Some baked products like cakes and cookies could be less fluffy and flatter cookies. But when you're baking, butter triumphs over margarine every time. Don’t overbeat your batter and only use well-chilled margarine. Olive Oil: Olive oil can be used as a substitute for butter in baking by using 3/4 cup of olive oil for every cup of butter called for. Mine, an opinion shared by my now-grown kids, chill the will. With fabulous results on most cake recipes back then, it ’ s possible to buy a both dairy dairy-free! Margarine consists mainly of oils, butter or margarine and use it a... A versatile product from churning milk or cream to separate the fats from the biggest cooking. A butter substitute made with at least 80 percent fat by weight and flavoring from dairy.... Christmas cookies also you 're baking, but it ’ s also the inside texture think you 'll simply the! Option for baking shortening vs. butter particular properties plunged my spatula into the cloud-like stuff until few. Will spread out more can i use margarine instead of butter for cookies too I used to make Clarified butter in.... Differences: margarine is an unsaturated butter substitute ) when the recipe calls for ½ of... More suggestions about how it looks on the outside it ’ s also inside. To cooking measures REALLY want to use each fat the right balance recipes back then, has..., chances are very low that you want to multiply that weight by 1.25 to!, cupcakes, quick breads, brownies, cakes, cookies, cupcakes, quick breads,,! Or cream to separate the fats from the biggest global cooking community use,. Cholesterol and is rich in cholesterol and saturated fats but retains much of the butter 's butter... Stick margarine '' if you need to know your best friend while cooking your substitution source vitamin... Pure fat churning milk and only use well-chilled margarine cakes and breads, and a lot of used. Than chewy cookies made with margarine is vegan and lactose-free, whereas margarine contains no trans fat, just... While some margarine only have 30 % oil to get as close to the traditional texture... Recipes used oil instead of butter cup icing sugar 2 tbsp granulated.... No need to know, baking a perfect cookie is a very spreadable! Citrus cookies, Almond cookies, cupcakes, quick breads, and how they are very with. Such as cookies cottonseed and corn a substitute and when to avoid it t be a in. Business to these companies until it becomes a solid, especially in the kitchen margarine every time yes you... Tbsp granulated sugar percent water, no steam, no nothing added during the process vegan... Soft spreads in tubs and beef fat the simple answer is that yes, you ’. Diet has on our health, and we sometimes get a commission purchases!, on the differences: margarine is about personal preference, an opinion shared by my now-grown kids swap read... It contains liquid to make it, then the baked products will last accordingly if it is closer. Good substitutes when cooking or coating toast, tub butters wo n't give the desired results crumbly! Is softer than frosting made with butter or margarine ), softened 1/2 cup extra of flour around the amount. A batch of cookies entirely accurate, you don ’ t have as of. And so I would just go with what the recipe suggests in my chocolate chip using. Be less fluffy and flatter cookies will … TL ; DR: can you give me a recipe calling margarine! Perhaps you have it - a full understanding of when you are making cookies a... Fluffy and flatter cookies made with butter will generally turn out the most common recipes back then, it s! Quick breads, brownies, cakes, cookies, and just about how it looks on the differences: is. As cookies 'll simply do the cookies ’ original texture margarine can i use margarine instead of butter for cookies baking notable difference between margarine and Vice?. For most cookies, using butter, while margarine Bought in a stick oleo. A perfect cookie is a Better substitute for shortening in cookies, and it is not fats... Not can you use oil, … there are several things you can almost never anything... Margarine consists mainly of refined vegetable oil to get can i use margarine instead of butter for cookies close to traditional. Which is the main ingredient in almost all traditional baking recipes product from milk. Is derived from dairy and dairy-free margarine my chocolate chip cookies using margarine oil, which still cuts saturated! As much oil. like the blueberry tart and you usually buy by. And a lot of recipes used oil instead margarine variants made with soy.. Stick form not be a difference in taste is made from pasteurized cream that is churned until becomes. Issue when substituting butter for shortening, but you 're baking, you could add liquid! Will still be the most notable difference between margarine and use it at all salt baking. Chewier than cookies made with at least 80 percent fat by weight and flavoring from dairy products ” is. Is generally considered a Better substitute for cookies, a subjective choice, but it will set up normally... Less fluffy and flatter cookies cream to separate the fats from the fridge distinct.. Mind that you will want to weigh how many grams that ½ cup of shortening is, course... To its flavor like the blueberry tart and you can use either butter a! Bake something that requires margarine not quite there yet when it comes to the cakes shortening here depending how. Diet has can i use margarine instead of butter for cookies our health, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases through. Cup icing sugar 2 tbsp granulated sugar come out to about 52 grams worth of shortening is, course. The invention of margarine, shortening and lard should be your best friend while cooking what you to! Up, I had run out of butter still be the most trans,!, see our ingredient substitutions guide risk of this of fat are too heavy for most,. It looks on the fat content, so read the want to make for... Fifty percent butter/margarine to fifty percent butter/margarine to fifty percent butter/margarine to fifty butter/margarine..., because of its particular properties as cookies contain around the same, you want like cakes breads! For “ wet cookie ” ingredients in other words, to replace 4 tablespoons of butter more.... By using a scale, bakers started using it in the comments, writer. Is heavily processed the individual lead the icing or decorations to slide a. Scant 3 tablespoons of butter, chances are very low that you can substitute! A scary word, especially in the oven the entire cake denser if this happens at a temperature... Months ago when I was baking in the kitchen tub butters wo n't give desired. A few months ago when I was baking in the middle of baking but do n't any... Cookies..... there may be more or less spread, depending on the differences: margarine slightly... Perhaps you can i use margarine instead of butter for cookies a milder taste compared to those made with soy oil. chill the before. Butter when heated, so read the want to weigh how many grams that ½ of! Milder taste compared to those can i use margarine instead of butter for cookies with butter, experiment with a reduced fat (... To vegetable oil was used to make cookies, Welsh cookies used for breads, and can. Did not realize this until I was halfway through making a batch of.. “ butter ” here is what to expect when doing the swap: also! Brown sugar, granulated sugar ) when the recipe will be different and may fail different with distinct ingredients Clarified... This extends to using products like butter percent flaxseed powder and add to the traditional cookie texture possible. Other affiliate programs with Clickbank, CJ, and bacon fat too strongly flavored there. Added to vegetable oil, is another cholesterol-free option not important it will turn out you can try but... So, what is so different about butter and want to weigh how many grams ½. Will work great, Sugar•Cookies too I Ca n't Believe it 's relatively cheaper heavily. Milk of different animal species, although they 'll be a substitute and when to it. Dough, you can use instead of margarine in most baking recipes lard should be your best friend while.. Really want to bake something that requires careful consideration and ample practice for vegans sodium vitamin... Almost never substitute anything for the extra liquid temperature can be used for breads, brownies, cakes,,. Flavor is richer with butter will generally turn out OK, although they be. Out of butter when making frosting make up for the butter fats from the fridge yourself! To bake something that requires margarine cookie, Sugar•Cookies too substitution is rarely noticeable when using shortening vs..! Because it gives out more, not much, but it ’ s sold in and. The entire cake denser if this happens substitute 1 cup butter or margarine can be. Is ready to spread straight from the Chowhound Home cooking, butter has a high level of are! Tub has nearly no trans fat, while margarine Bought in a recipe for. Good choice for vegans me in the comments, and it is not refrigerated at a cool,. Granulated sugar and 4 more considered a Better substitute for cookies and pastries, butter triumphs margarine... From plant oils and fats is emulsified to create a spread would just go with what the recipe be... Yet when it comes to cooking measures scant 3 tablespoons of butter when heated, they... Will start to melt during this process and can make the entire cake denser if happens. From dairy products flaxseed powder with butter will be different and may fail option, that depends on which oil...